Subscribe to this blog

  • RSS
  • RSS
    Google Reader or Homepage
    del.icio.us Items
    Add to My Yahoo!
    Subscribe with Bloglines
    Subscribe in NewsGator Online

    myFeedster
    Add to My AOL

Tags

Archives

Rail Station Design Competition
Wednesday, January 25, 2012 4:17 PM  

 

Montage of five designs for new Main Central Station 

Last night, in the beautiful Gerald D. Hines building at 811 Main, where the lobby sports tan leather sofas and dramatic white orchids, the Houston Downtown Management District hosted a competition featuring designs from five award-winning architectural firms.

The challenge: to design an iconic new Central Station - Main on Main Street between Capitol and Rusk. The station would also be the transfer point for three light-rail lines.

The five invited firms from around the country - including one Houston firm - were asked to consider into their design such factors as: openness, views of adjacent buildings, clarity of circulation, feasibility of construction and maintenance, even how the roof would look from a bird's eye view.

But the most important requirement was to design a station that would become a landmark for downtown Houston.

Crowd looking at five design entries for new stationAbout 350 community leaders, architects, design students and residents showed up to hear a 15-minute presentation by each architectural firm. The firms were: SHoP Architects; Lewis, Tsurumaki, Lewis Architects; Neil M. Denari Architects; Interloop-Architecture (Houston); and Snohetta, based in Norway and New York.

Each design was assigned a number at random, which did not represent a ranking. Before the formal presentations started, the crowd walked around displays and picked their favorites. Held on the 11th floor, the event overlooked the intersection where the new rail station would be built.

"We wanted this to be an iconic station...where three lines cross each other - East End, Southeast and the North extension of the Red Line, " said Bob Eury, executive director of the Downtown District, adding that the competition was a joint project with METRO and Houston Rapid Transit (HRT), a joint venture building our light-rail lines.

Lonnie Hoogeboom, an architect who is the director of planning and design at the Downtown Management District, said he was delighted at last night's turn-out. He called the five firms innovative problem solvers, which figured out how to create within highly restrictive design constraints a landmark that was aesthetically pleasing.

SHoP Architects (entry #1) compared its soaring design to the archway of St. Louis and said it wanted to build a station that was in scale to the historic buildings around it, which included front entrances that were three stories high.

Paul Lewis (entry #2) said his team was intrigued by the platform restrictions and the yellow median strip. Its strategy was to take the restrictions and float volume over the side and provide a protective umbrella.

Neil M. Denari Architects (entry #3) pointed to existing Houston icons - the Astrodome, the Pennzoil Place designed by Phillip Johnson as inspiration for its steel-constructed station that popped with fire-engine red. An icon is an image, and Denari Architects said it wanted to bring that level of graphic quality into 3-D form - and then create forms that were scaled to the body, not to the city. Aerial view from 11th floor of new station site

This was my favorite design, and afterwards, a young man next to me leaned over and echoed my sentiments, saying, "That was beautiful, wasn't it? I love it!"

I had to leave before hearing presentations #4 and #5 - but click here to see close-up artist renderings of all the designs, including drawings and explanations.  

Then comment and vote online for your favorite design. Do you like the shape or color? Will it make your METRORail experience better? Does it represent downtown?

A jury will consider your comments when it selects the winning design.

 

Comments

DominicMazoch said:

Where the East/Southeast lines cross an existing part of the elder line.  The station will be new, but the line IS already there.

# January 25, 2012 8:31 PM

Jessie said:

This is awesome!

# January 26, 2012 10:08 AM

Martin Miglioretti said:

Were the five invited design firms compensated for their work?

# January 27, 2012 2:38 PM

Alan said:

It would be nice to be able to get to the tunnel without getting rained on.  They're all beautiful, though. Wish we would have done more design competitions . . .

# January 30, 2012 7:56 AM

Mary Sit said:

Just to be clear - I was expressing my opinion only when I said I liked Entry #3. This is not the official position of METRO. Detailed analysis will be performed on the constructability of each of the entries. This information will be given to the jurors to help them in their decision. The final announcement will be made in early March.

We still want to hear from you, so please vote on your favorite and tell us why. Your opinion will be considered by the jury.

# February 2, 2012 3:21 PM

Mary Sit said:

Martin Miglioretti,

Yes, the five firms were compensated. Each received an honorarium of $20,000. This fee included all the design work and their travel expenses.

# February 2, 2012 3:29 PM

Guy W said:

My ranking: 5,3,1,4,2.

#5: good looks, good rain cover, small footprint.  OTOH, what about stability in the frequent high winds?

#3: less ambitious than 5 or 1, yet still "iconic".  Less rain cover, but no wind problem.  Would not like it if Metro didn't keep the red paint fresh, tho!  

#1: I like it, but would it overwhelm the site? Good rain cover, but wind a problem?

#4: might actually be ok, as far as the form.  However, the presentation overplays the vivid colors, which I doubt would last.

#2: reminds me of early-70s designs that didn't age well.  Functionality similar to #3, but graceless.

# February 5, 2012 1:04 PM

fred said:

#5 good design with plenty of rain coverage.  #1 I like the idea of reduced humidity on the platform.  Take design #5 and incorporate #1's PCM & air flow.

# February 13, 2012 10:07 AM
New Comments to this post are disabled