Subscribe to this blog

  • RSS
  • RSS
    Google Reader or Homepage
    del.icio.us Items
    Add to My Yahoo!
    Subscribe with Bloglines
    Subscribe in NewsGator Online

    myFeedster
    Add to My AOL

Tags

METRO Pulls Off Industry Firsts with Q Card
Wednesday, April 09, 2008 7:10 PM



Nine days ago, we did something so rare in the industry that other transit agencies nationwide are touting METRO as a model.

We completed the switch to a smart card called the Q Card, and we completed our fare restructuring – at the same time!  

Last week at a national conference in Boston of the American Public Transportation Association (APTA), the premiere transportation trade group, METRO was the envy of other transit agencies.  

“Most of the other transit professionals in Boston thought it was a Herculean accomplishment to not only implement new technology but a new fare structure at the same time,” said Jeff Linton, METRO’s director of revenue. “We got rid of 65 different types of magnetic and paper tickets and reduced it to two: Q Card and cash. That was to our counterparts in the industry, an amazing feat to accomplish in such a short time frame from January 2 to March 31.”

Other transit agencies that have switched to a smart card continue to use an assortment of fare media and passes.

Three main factors contributed to our success. First, we conducted 11 months of extensive testing of the system that began in February 2007. That testing included Q Card usse with our beta group of testers, METRO employees and consultants. Testing the Q Card long before the general public began using it helped us work out the glitches.

In addition, METRO conducted a comprehensive marketing and customer information campaign – blanketing the city with signs, brochures, commercials, and advertisements. The local media  - from neighborhood freebies to the Houston Chronicle – covered the switchover. We created “Ask Me” teams who wore red vests and stood where are customers travel, handing out Q Card starter kits.

And thirdly, we layered that with “the due diligence and tremendous effort put forth by METRO’s staff to make sure all the different components of the Q Card worked and came together,” said Linton.

We had three critical dates with a separate marketing component within each date: Jan 2 – official kick-off of the Q Card; Feb. 29 – last day of cash transfers; and March 31 – last day to use magnetic striped fare media.

We also were driven by a mandate from the top to make the Q Card easy and convenient.

“The president and CEO, Frank Wilson, had a goal to ensure that customers had the ability to not only receive Q Cards, but to have locations where they could add value across the city of Houston and our service area,” said Linton.

So we developed a broad network of retail stores – Kroger, Randalls, Fiesta, Valero gas stations – where customers could pick up a Q Card and load money. We have about 370 devices at these locations. Click here for the full list.

We developed our Web site so that on Day One, customers could add to their balance on-line. As of yesterday, 305 customers loaded money on-line, and 604 Ride Sponsor clients loaded money. Total on-line revenue: $36,000.

We made sure our 16 transit centers were staffed Monday through Saturday for customers to pick up Q Cards and add money.

And METRO, along with its fare vendor, invented something no other agency has: the BBR – back-of-the-bus reloader where passengers can use cash to add money to their Q Card.

“We are the first and only one in the country to do that,” said Linton. “Our goal was to make sure there were plenty of opportunities for customers to get Q Cards and get reloads.”

In fact, the BBRs appear to be a hit with our customers. More customers are using BBRs to reload their Q Card than any other method, said Linton. As of yesterday, METRO recorded 16,058 transactions with BBRs, totaling $34,271.

Most of our customers are using the Q Card – 71 percent as of yesterday. That translates to 186,342 transactions, totaling $145,705.50.

Cash customers made up 28 percent with 54,894 transactions and $57,330 in revenue.

Single-use tickets on the Ticket Vending Machines (TVM) were used by 1 percent of our customers with 3,570 transactions, totaling $3,570 in revenue.

(All transaction numbers include transfers, which is why revenues are lower than transactions.)

While Houston has the same number of buses as Philadelphia and Boston, METRO’s service area sprawls out over hundreds of square miles. “Our geographic size made the implementation of the Q Card more challenging,” said Linton. “We had to reach not only our Park & Ride riders but our urban riders, as well. We had two distinct customer groups.”

It is appropos that next year’s fare collection conference will be held in the Bayou City.

“Everybody wants to come to Houston to find out how we did it,” said Linton.

Posted by Mary Sit
Filed under:

Comments

DominicMazoch said:

Q i so easy that a pigeon can use it.......

# April 9, 2008 7:36 PM

DominicMazoch said:

I think the thing works is that there are two platforms:  Money or Q.  And only transfers with Q.  Transactions on the bus/platforms is quick.  Almost the transit version of the West Park TR--EZ tgag only!

# April 9, 2008 7:42 PM

kevin whited said:

** That was to our counterparts in the industry, an amazing feat to accomplish in such a short time frame from January 2 to March 31.”

Other transit agencies that have switched to a smart card continue to use an assortment of fare media and passes.

Three main factors contributed to our success. First, we conducted 11 months of extensive testing of the system that began in February 2007.**

Umm, that's one way to spin it.

And it sounds a lot better than the fact that the entire stored-value-card rollout ran WAY behind schedule, which is the reality of the matter.

# April 9, 2008 8:14 PM

Royko said:

Gee!

METREAUX was supposed to have a SVC system implemented for the tram well over FOUR YEARS AGO!!!

How many millions of precious taxpayer dollars have been wasted just getting the Tram system to be able to handle SVC's.

Give us a break on this glorious accomplishment, Please?

# April 10, 2008 12:51 AM

don said:

There should be a place to tap the Q cards on board the trains.

# April 10, 2008 7:41 AM

Royko #2 said:

The bar has been set and the possibilities are endless. I am going to Chicago next week and I was hoping to use my Q Card there. I will try it out and let everyone know including METREAUX. I still have three dollars on a SVC just in case METREAUX changes back to the old system in a new pilot.

# April 10, 2008 7:48 AM

M'neeka said:

It's sad to me that the criterion for excellence is apparently only that it works well for the transit agency and to hell with the customers.

This project was repeatedly delayed for years.  Then the customers were rushed to be terribly inconvenienced to spend **their time and money** to preserve the value of fare media which they had already purchased in good faith. Media which continued to be sold by Metro even at date which would make it impossible for anyone to use it in it's entirety prior to the switch.

Customers with concerns on these issues were ignored, misled and even lied to.

This whole thing is so many shades of wrong, I cannot begin to spell them out here.

Am I bitter?  Oh yeah!!  Because I have no reason to believe that anything else Metro does will be handled with anymore ethics or class than this was...especially since it was such a rousing success FOR THEM.  Their intentions and priorities are crystal clear, given their rush to heartily congratulate themselves on a shoddy job and to publicize to the transit world as a model.  

# April 10, 2008 8:52 AM

Cedric Collins said:

*Royko #2 said:  "I still have three dollars on a SVC just in case METREAUX changes back to the old system in a new pilot."

That's just pathetic!  You might as well keep that worthless SVC as a keepsake.

*don said:  "There should be a place to tap the Q cards on board the trains."

Why?  Most importantly---where?

Is it because people wait until the last minute to when the train is already at the station and then they run for it?  If that's the case, then METRO needs to get rid of the Q Box on the TVMs.

Dominic,

       What you said is SOOOO true---and funny (the 1st thing you said).

Royko,

     Where on this blog does it talk about the SVCs?

Royko said:  "Give us a break on this glorious accomplishment, Please?"

NOPE.  Congrats to METRO on this wonderful accomplishment!  BRAVO!

M'neeka,

       What are you trying to imply with what you said?

# April 10, 2008 9:26 AM

Elizabeth said:

DominicMazoch said:  

"Q is so easy that a pigeon can use it......."

Too funny!

# April 10, 2008 1:44 PM

Realistic said:

My only complaint ok make that 2 with the Q Card is that it raised prices and that it would have been easier if METRO had let the cards phase out instead of requiring a set date of transfer. I know many people who are overseas and no exceptions are being made for them and the hundreds of dollars remaining on their svcs.

METRO should have established a longer window of magnetic card usage since no one could buy them anywhere anyway after sometime in January. That would have made sense... too bad METRO didn't bother getting together with any sort of a focus group on anything...

# April 10, 2008 2:31 PM

JLN said:

One problem I have a QCard is that if you take that 40 from TC Jester and want to go Ella and Pinemont, it going to cost you $2.00, compared to the old $1.00 transfer and explaining to the driver where you came from and where you are going...   I have tried it and the QCard representative told me that I can't get my money back on my QCard since I changed directions...

# April 10, 2008 6:27 PM

P&R Rider said:

Metro did stop selling the Blue and Red cards in Feb 08.  The Ride-Share companies (big & small companies downtown) had bought cards from Metro previously and were still selling/giving them to employees in early March '08 to allow them to ride until the big switch.

Metro stopped selling the 365 day green card in Dec '07 so they would all expire by 4-1-08.

However, as I have blogged here many times before, Metro was shortsighted to make the last day to transfer balances the same day as the last day to use the passes.

Sheila Jackson-Lee, where are you when there is an injustice to right where you could get in front of the camera and criticize the treatment of the poor Metro riders?

# April 10, 2008 6:40 PM

DominicMazoch said:

One of the "Ask Me" guys showed me something at N.Sheperd P&R this AM.  I was wondering if there is some way I know how many trips I have made.  There IS.

If you get on a bus, or rail platform, hold the Q next to the tap box.  It will show how much money you have on it, and how many trips you have made.

I wish the credit card people would take note.  Some of my cards have a "bad read".  Tell merchants about Q, and they say "huummmm....."

# April 10, 2008 6:57 PM

DominicMazoch said:

Thanks for enjoying the comment.

I don't remember who brought up the pigeons idea, but I thought the blog could use it as its "caveman".

If one cannot laugh, that one is not human!

# April 10, 2008 7:00 PM

DominicMazoch said:

OK, P&R rider came up with the pigeons....

# April 10, 2008 7:21 PM

P&R Rider said:

Thank you Dominic, for the credit.  I have been raving about pigeons over on the DART topic.

And, I'm pretty sure the "hold the Q-Card on the reader" instruction to see your balance was published by Metro in one of their brochures.  

I am personally up to 113 rides on my 1st Q-Card and have gotten 2 sets of 5 free rides.  For those who care about such trivia, the number of rides just continues to build and does not reset to zero when you hit 50.  Also, the "free rides" to not count on your total, so you will see the balance and the number of rides stay at the same number until you use up the 5 free ones.  Then the counter will increase and the balance will decrease on the next paid ride.

# April 11, 2008 7:10 AM

mizz_porkie said:

M'neeka,

I am one of the resident Bus Operators who blog here.  I can understand your point, but at the same time, the cost of EVERYTHING has gone up....WAY UP and folks are still paying for it.  

I have been employed here some 13 1/2 years, the fare had just went to $1.00 from .85c then.  People did not want to pay then!!  Then they instituted the DDREADFUL DAYPASS AND FREEDOM PASS, FROM THERE THE WEEKLY AND MONTHLY all to the dismay of the "front-line" employees (OPERATORS).  We told them it would be big trouble with these types of fare media.   and here we are 14 or 15 years later with the problems!!

NO-ONE wants to pay!  I along with my husband used to be Owner-Operator truck drivers.  We ran 48 states under our own authority (no middle man) and idling at truck stops, wear and tear, fuel, tires, cost us approx $10,00.00 per year and we only had 2 trucks and they were both under warranty with a $1200.00 note and  a$1,000.00 note!!  so what i am really saying is do the MATH!! and you will see metro's point!!

FOLKS pay for what they want!!   WHEN THEY CAN PUT UP A PITIFUL MOUTH...AND SOMEONE ACKNOWLEDGES, THEN ITS ON!

BTW...I HAVE A 3,000SQ FT HOUSE NEVER SAW A LIGHT BILL OVER $250.00 AND HECK IT WAS THAT IN THE WINTER...LAST YEAR DURING THE SUMMER MONTHS, IT WAS RIGHT AT $600.00.  DO YOU THINK RELIANT ENERGY ENTERTAINED MY COMPLAINTS????

HECK NO!!

# April 11, 2008 9:24 PM

P&R Rider said:

Mizz_porkie; You can switch electric providers at www.powertochoose.org and save a little money.  The savings will be about 5 to 10% which will help some.  CenterPoint Energy (the old HL&P) owns the wires and poles and you choose who to buy power from.

# April 12, 2008 11:09 PM

wi11ie said:

ready for pickup: http://houston.craigslist.org/zip/640273538.html

worth the trip?

uh....no..

wi11ie

# April 13, 2008 9:56 AM

mizz_porkie said:

wi11ie....only you'd found that!

# April 13, 2008 1:19 PM

Ex-298 Rider said:

Well I resisted the Q card but now that I have been fully assimilated by the Metro collective I can say that everything Metro does is benevolent and kind with only my best interests at heart.

I know this to be true because they showed me how to make the same trip to work in the TMC for less than I ever paid with the 30 day pass.  This was $84 at a discount for Zone 3 (I got on at NWTC and not Katy).

I discovered, the first time I used my shiny new card, that my fare had gone from $3 to $3.5...for a 12 mile trip...but did I whine, or complain?  Heck yes, but the big shiny Metro building did not hear my cries for mercy ($3.50 for 12miles?  Are you people just st00pid??) and so I vowed to find a cheaper way.

85 Antoine stops 2 blocks from my house- $1 to downtown...transfer to the rail- no charge.

In the evening, reverse that trip.  

Overall, I'm saving at least $5.00/day and now, since I don't drive to the NWTC, I'm saving an additional $1.50 a day in gas.

So I've gone from $84/month on the old system + $31 a month for gas to $44/month.

THANK YOU METRO!!!

# April 22, 2008 7:43 AM

Southern said:

*don said:  "There should be a place to tap the Q cards on board the trains.*

The only problem with that is, nobody would tap UNLESS they see metro police at the rail station that they're debarking at.. So that's probably not a good idea. :)

# May 1, 2008 10:31 AM
New Comments to this post are disabled